
IIAC 2023 World Ranking Announcement - World Ranking 005 - Merit Prize
Memory of the Eye
Author: Cho Jae-Sun / South Korea
Aquarium Size/W120 x D60 x H45 (cm)
Comments from Andrew M. Senske
amazing use of stone, creating flow and feel, plant species is very nice for this layout and amazing attention to detail. A very powerful scape !
Comments from Diego Marinelli
This work is truly incredible because it is very difficult to build such a complex structure with seiryu stones. the combination of plants and fish is beautiful for a final result of a magnificent work that deserves my best compliments.
Comments from Nishimura Noboru
Very bold stonework left an impression on me. Using too many stones tends to result in a monotonous layout, but this work has a lot to offer, and you can enjoy it no matter how many times you look at it.
Comments from Gary Wu
If not observe in detail could overlook the difficulty of this unique hardscape. This hardscape arrangement is superb. Proper choice of plants, healthy vegetation also with proper coverage. Well done.
Comments from Frederic Fuss
An imaginative rocky landscape. The impressive structures seem so elongated that you might think you are dealing with a distortion effect in Photoshop. I feel tremendous tension and excitement in this layout. The vanishing point seems to be behind the large rock formation on the left here, far away from the focus points. It feels like the whole formation is in motion. A very bold and interesting design. By using a single type of stone and fewer, different plants, an enormous coherence could be achieved. However, this is at the expense of the color palette. Overall, I find the coloring extremely cold with too much green and blue. The few stems of Rotala walichii cannot compensate for them. I think a selection of stones with a brownish tone would have made for a more pleasing color balance. I would have liked to see the gray sand changed at the same time. Unfortunately, the swarm Priscilla maxilaris is not optimally positioned. Due to their own colors, they blur strongly with the background of rocks. And because of the extreme vectors, it would have been nice to see the swarm swim out of this gap. A courageous work and I wish you that your courage will be rewarded with a good placement!
Leave your comments